Regional Representation

Improved representation of rural areas: a major feature of Proportional Representation

2017 Election:

Loss of Local MLAs?

In 2018 there was misinformation spread, suggesting that voters would lose their local MLA with Pro Rep.

Fact: There were “local MLAs” in all versions of Pro Rep on the 2018 BC referendum ballot.

Pro Rep always incorporates some type of multi-member electoral districts, either real or virtual. BC had many two-member districts until quite recently, and these larger districts posed no problem in practice.

With Pro Rep systems your chances of having a local or regional MLA who supports your views almost doubles, so in meaningful terms your local or regional representation would be hugely improved with Pro Rep.

Unlike now, every sizable region would have both reps in government to get things done, AND reps in opposition to hold them accountable to get things done.

Graph (2018) of B.C. representation: orange and green were the only areas with an MLA in government 2017 – 2020:

Confusion of proportionality with district sizes

Some 2018 referendum campaign misinformation accused Pro Rep of shifting power from the hinterland to the city.

Fact: The Pro Rep voting style would have zero effect on the balance of power in BC between Vancouver and the rest of the province, or between urban and rural areas.

Traditionally, the independent Electoral Boundaries Commission (EBC) sets the ratio of MLAs to citizens to be higher in rural areas than urban areas, for practical reasons of travel distances involved in MLA work. Pro Rep options can’t change this. The size of the legislature increases every so often since the government can add MLAs, who would likely be assigned by the EBC to the areas with increasing population. Other than that, the backcountry would have the same fraction of MLAs under any voting system.

Facebook share button

Home (Highlights) | Quick Guide to Voting | Voting Systems as Gardening | Pro Rep vs FPTP: Intro. | 17 Benefits of First-Past-The-Post | Economy, Stability, etc. | Voter Turnout | Simpler Voting | Better Politicians?! | True Majority Rule | Regional Representation | Questions and Answers | VIDEOS | About VotingBC